Audit written to `output/critiques/claude/chapter_12.characters_wrong.md`. Full audit text:

---

# Chapter 12 — Let-Characters-Be-Wrong / Competence-Default Audit

id: characters_wrong | owner: claude | chapter: 12 ("The Memory He Chooses")

## Section 1 — sweep verdict

WRONGNESS-PRESENT — instances:

- Theo, "He had, in the intervening twenty-two hours, made it a thing. ... At ten past six he moved the chairs to the worktable in the middle room ... At quarter past he moved them back" — blind spot. June's text said "don't make it a thing"; he does exactly that and narrates the staging as logistics, not anxiety.
- Theo, "I typed, *Just to clarify*, and then I typed, *Not that it matters*, and then I deleted both, because--" — saying the wrong thing (twice, in draft) and then choosing delay; the false errand credit still stands in the group thread at chapter end.
- Theo, "You were on the frame errand." — misunderstanding (minor): he did not know June was on the errand and is caught restating what she just told him.
- Theo, "There's also water." — defensive for no good reason. June punctures the staging ("You set a table for two index cards") and his defense is to point at more staging.
- Theo, block-capital record misses the true part — blind spot. He writes the formula, the coats, and "you'd never know," and June has to reach over and tap the card: "Put the outlet plate in. Off the wall, sitting on the floor with its two little screws. If you're going to paint it, that's the true part." His inventory reflex privileged the competence-content of her memory over its human detail, and she had to correct the record.
- June, "And don't make me noble about it. I mean it. No standing figure gazing upon the white wall." — defensive for no good reason. Theo has asked only process questions (white, coats); no one has offered her nobility or pity. She armors against a reading that was not coming.
- June, "Seven." / "I know." — micro-defensiveness: she asked the question, he confirmed, and she still reclaims the last word.
- Mara (offstage), the group-thread thanks "For the errand" Theo was not on — a standing misunderstanding nobody corrects, with June complicit by silence (carried from Ch11).

The sweep is not a clean pass everywhere: the central handoff dialogue itself contains almost no voiced missteps — every question Theo asks aloud is the right question, and every answer June gives is clean. The wrongness lives at the perimeter (staging, drafts, offstage thread) and in one mid-scene correction (outlet plate). Two of the four behaviors (misunderstanding, wrong-thing-said) are present only in trace amounts; blind spots and unprovoked defensiveness carry the chapter.

## Section 2 — per major character

**Theo Brennan** — gets-wrong field: "believes delay is kindness; believes being indispensable is the same as being loved." — verdict: **OPERATED, with one contaminating clause (Finding 1).**

Operating evidence, both clauses:
- Delay-as-kindness: "For two days he had taken out a third card and put it back blank. He had uncapped the pen, capped it, read Odile's card again, and found a reason to price hardware, answer email, move a frame." Plus the deleted clarification texts — he lets Mara's misattribution stand rather than "make it a thing," which is the delay belief wearing its kindness costume, correctly uncorrected by the chapter.
- Indispensability-as-love: the table set for two index cards; the second glass "poured after he drank the first without noticing"; and on receiving June's most guarded material, his first voiced response is "What white, exactly?" — he converts intimacy into a supplies list, and the conversion costs him the true part of her memory until she fixes his card. At close he converts the evening back into kit-packing: "brushes, the rag roll, the Dom receipt."

The contamination (Finding 1): "He had four questions and three of them were repairs. ... *Who decided your wall was the one that had to be ready* was not even a question; it was an accusation aimed at someone who was not in the room." The restraint itself is card-binding ("Theo wants to fix it ... He should not. His growth here is custody, not solution") and is not the finding. The finding is the quality of the self-diagnosis: a man whose declared wrongness is that he *believes* his fixing is kindness should not, in real time, correctly X-ray his third impulse as displaced aggression. Trade vocabulary ("a repair," "immediate as a frame wanting a shim") is in-voice inventory; "an accusation aimed at someone who was not in the room" is a therapist's verdict. His voice card specifies "delayed recognition of his own desire" — this is instant, accurate recognition. The focused check ("he should still default to overpreparation and repair questions") is satisfied for overpreparation, massively and on the page; for repair questions, the impulses arrive but his containment is flawless and self-annotated, which is the competence default operating inside the interiority even while the behavior conforms.

**June Park** — gets-wrong field: "mistakes being understood for being pitied; assumes choosing herself requires choosing alone." — verdict: clause 1 **OPERATED** ("And don't make me noble about it. I mean it." — she converts Theo's attentive, process-only reception into incoming ennobling and strikes preemptively; he had given her no cause); clause 2 **NO-TRIGGER** (the Philadelphia/New York decision is offstage and protected by the packet — "Theo does not know about Nia, Philadelphia, Dana, Kessler" — so no scene can engage choosing-alone here; the chapter still gestures at the posture physically: she never unfolds her own card, "She set it face down on her knee," the tote stays "against her shin," "the strap of the tote was still around her ankle" — guarded sharing consistent with the field without a live trigger).

Counter-candidate considered and passed: June's reception of Theo's memory is four-for-four perfect — "Don't find out before tomorrow ... It's better as the envelope," "The clothespins with nothing on them. That's the painting," "I'm not going to put laundry on the line to make it friendlier" (which Theo confirms: "I don't want it friendlier"). This is the most suspiciously well-adjusted run in the chapter. It survives because (a) naming what is actually good in someone's material is June's owned care move per the reading guide ("precise, unsentimental praise — rare and therefore devastating"), (b) "I don't want to know either" implicates her in the avoidance — shared cowardice, not oracle wisdom — and (c) the anti-friendly stance mirrors her own "don't make me noble," i.e., she is projecting her armor onto his material and the text merely lets the projection land correctly once. It is at the ceiling of allowable competence, not over it.

Focused check (June not too wise about her own wound): **passes.** She protects the memory from nobility but never summarizes it. Nearest approaches, quoted: "I billed zero hours because it was my own room, which was my own genius decision" (sardonic, local, deflective — not a wound summary) and "It never fully runs clear. I gave it ten more minutes and packed the tray" (the wound carried entirely by process detail, unexplained). She never says erasure, never connects the wall to safety or to a pattern, and the prohibited "I erased myself" formulation does not appear in any costume.

**Odile Marchetti** — gets-wrong field: "assumes the manipulation she can survive is manipulation others can forgive quickly." — verdict: **NO-TRIGGER.** She is materially present only as the assignment card ("I WILL NOT HAVE AMBUSHES IN MY ROOM"), per the packet's restriction; her wrongness structurally cannot engage before the reveal, and the card states logistics, not knowledge. Acceptable.

**Mara (offstage)** — gets-wrong field: "thinks smoothing is always kindness." — verdict: **OPERATED**, remotely: her group-thread thanks smoothed the errand into a tidy credit to Theo, manufacturing a misattribution that Theo cannot now correct without "making it a thing" and that June lets stand. The smoothing created friction precisely because it was kind.

## Section 3 — friction yield

- Theo's staging — FRICTION ("Theo. It's two index cards. You set a table for two index cards." — his anxiety is named to his face, he cannot defend it on the merits, and the jab bookends the scene at her exit: "Thanks for the water I didn't drink.")
- Theo's deleted texts / errand misattribution — FRICTION (the false credit survives the chapter; June's flat "I know you weren't on it. I was." leaves him restating the obvious, and the uncorrected thread deepens the public-couple paperwork — cost deferred into the right ledger.)
- Theo's "There's also water." — FRICTION, weakest instance (the cost is one beat of exposure; June sits down anyway and the scene moves on.)
- Theo's record missing the outlet plate — FRICTION (his competence at recording is shown insufficient; the memory's owner must amend his card on the page, and the amendment is preserved in his block capitals: "OUTLET PLATE OFF, SCREWS WITH IT.")
- June's "don't make me noble" — FRICTION (it stands as a standing prohibition on his painting, never apologized for or walked back; he must hold her memory under her rules. Light, but it is not announced-then-resolved, so not COSTUMED.)
- Theo's four-questions paragraph — COSTUMED in the narration layer (the impulse is announced and neutralized within the same paragraph, sorted and labeled, at zero visible cost to the conversation: "He picked up the middle pen instead and pulled a blank card toward him." See Finding 1; the costume here is self-insight rather than apology.)

## Focused extra checks

1. **Theo's emotional competence:** overpreparation default — present and costly. Repair-question default — impulses present but suppressed with too-clean self-taxonomy; this is Finding 1. He does not get to be the man who wants to fix it; he gets to be the man who has already filed the want.
2. **June's wisdom about the erased wall** — passes; evidence quoted in Section 2. Her wiseness about Theo's memory was weighed as the strongest counter-candidate and passed at the ceiling.
3. **Ch13/Ch16 advance-solving — no solve.** Ch13: no painting occurs; June's "That's the painting" pre-commits her composition, but the chapter card mandates the memory be given "plainly enough that she can paint it tomorrow," and Ch13's actual payoff load (the paintings in the public room, the midpoint kiss obligation per the thread ledger) is untouched. Theo's train annotation ("GREEN FIRST. ORANGE INTERVAL RIGHT SIDE. DEAD SALMON BEFORE WHITE.") is rendering custody, not interpretation. Ch16: neither memory is framed as fear anywhere; June never approaches naming "erasing herself for safe rooms"; Theo never reframes the wall as leaving. The fear canvases remain unspent.

Protected-thread spot checks, in passing: no nephew language, no Odile-knowledge statement, no catalog object, no kiss/confession, no Philadelphia leak, hidden Week 3 panel referenced only as object ("the panel behind them exactly where he had put it weeks ago, unlabeled, painted side to the wall"). Clean.

## Chapter verdict

**TOO-COMPETENT (1 finding)**

The chapter's wrongness architecture is otherwise sound — both leads' fields operate with on-page cost, and the one finding is surgical, not structural.

**REVISION ORDERS:**

1. **Theo Brennan** — field: "believes delay is kindness; believes being indispensable is the same as being loved." Beat: the four-questions paragraph ("He had four questions and three of them were repairs. ... it was an accusation aimed at someone who was not in the room."). Order: keep the restraint (card-binding — he must not fix her memory) but remove the clean psychological verdict. Cut or blur "was not even a question; it was an accusation aimed at someone who was not in the room" — Theo may sort his impulses with trade vocabulary ("a repair," "a frame wanting a shim") but may not correctly diagnose his own displaced aggression in real time; his field is that he believes his fixing is kindness, so the third question should feel to him like the most helpful one, discarded for a reason he does not examine. To make the default audible rather than filed: let one repair question start to leave his mouth and reroute mid-breath — e.g., "Why didn't the—" becoming "What white, exactly?" — so the swerve happens in dialogue where June receives it (her existing flat answer "Decorator's White. Benjamin Moore. Flat." already serves; no dialogue diagnosis, no new lines required from her). What it must cost: the swerve is visible, unexplained, and unredeemed in-beat; the existing outlet-plate correction then reads as the price of the same reflex rather than an isolated beat. Do not soften this into a charming tic — the spec is a man whose helpfulness is a blind spot, not a quirk he curates.
