# Ripple-Effects Audit - Chapter 13

EVENT: Midpoint kiss / Philadelphia offer / showcase deadline - ch 13 - connected parties: June, Theo, Odile, Mara, Priya, Ben, Ruth, Sam, Luis, Nia, Asha, cohort, Marchetti Rooms / Sonia's social web

PROPAGATION: PASS-PENDING - per party:
- June: HEARD/EXPERIENCED ch 13 - "June turned and caught Theo's jacket lapel" and later sees Nia's text: "PHL board said yes. They want to make the offer formal. Call tomorrow before you talk yourself out of it."
- Theo: HEARD/EXPERIENCED ch 13 - "He accepted what she had done and kept the brush away from the scarf"; he knows only "Nia," because June says that and puts the phone away.
- Mara: HEARD/SAW ch 13 - "Mara looked at the phone once, lowered it against her sweater" and delays sending the photo: "I can't send the photo tonight."
- Odile: HEARD/SAW-PARTIAL ch 13 - "At the roster table, Odile wrote something beside a name and did not look up." This is plausible hidden knowledge/controlled nonreaction, not absence.
- Priya: HEARD/SAW ch 13 - "I noticed. I am choosing not to be helpful about why."
- Ruth/Sam/Ben/Luis/cohort: HEARD/SAW ch 13 through the photo-room context; weakest propagation accepted is Ruth's exact label, "Committee chairs," before the kiss, and the lack of public joke afterward.
- Nia: HEARD/ACTED ch 13 by text; she knows the board said yes, not June's context.
- Asha: UNAWARE (plausible: yes). Asha is not present and has not yet been contacted about the offer/referral thread.

FIRST-ORDER: PASS - direct effects are present on page:
- Kiss/public photo: "The kiss entered the evening the way the wet panels had entered it: present, inconvenient, not available for group discussion."
- Showcase deadline: "The last Tuesday will be open for two hours. A small showcase... Each pair will make one joint piece for it."
- Joint subject: "`Same room,' he said. 'Two views.'" and Odile records "The room after class."
- Formal offer: "It was not a fantasy. That was the problem."

SECOND-ORDER: RIPPLES-PENDING - behavior/economy/relationships:
- behavior: present in seed form. Mara's delayed photo, Theo's Thursday size options, June hiding the phone, and Priya's tact all create future behavior obligations.
- economy/work: present in seed form. Philadelphia becomes a formal paid offer with board approval; this must affect Ch15/Ch22.
- relationships: present in seed form. The public couple category now has a kiss/photo artifact and the private relationship has a concealed offer.
- Because no downstream chapter exists yet, these are not fully testable on later pages. Due-by: Ch14 for kiss/catalog/panel fallout; Ch15 for formal offer pressure; Ch16 for kiss+offer pressure in the fear assignment.

UNCLEAN: PASS-PENDING - open consequences:
- Photo remains delayed until tomorrow; exact circulation is open.
- Formal offer call is due tomorrow; June has not told Theo.
- Thursday pickup/panel options are promised.
- `After Class` is assigned but unresolved.
- Fake relationship, nephew identity, Odile knowledge, Priya/Ben outcome, and June's stay/leave decision all remain protected.

WEB: PASS - linked prior events named:
- Ch12 reciprocal memory custody directly causes the paintings/kiss.
- Ch09 Nia/Asha material-path event becomes formal through Nia's text.
- Ch08 continuing Tuesday table and public couple social web raise the cost of the photo.
- Ch11 forms/category pressure echoes in PARK / BRENNAN appearing under the future joint piece.
- Ch07/Ch08 artifact/hidden-portrait thread remains structurally parallel but protected.

Event verdict: RIPPLES-PENDING (due-by Ch16).

Revision orders:
- Ch14: first-order/second-order ripple required - show Thursday pickup/panel-size logistics and post-kiss awkwardness without confession; catalog handoff must grow from Theo's urge to help.
- Ch15: second-order economic/work ripple required - the formal Philadelphia offer must become concretely attractive and deadline-bearing, not mood texture.
- Ch16: relationship ripple required - fear assignment must carry both the kiss and June's concealed offer pressure while preserving protected reveals.
- Trackers updated: `output/event_ripple_tracker.md`, `output/thread_ledger.md`, `output/timeline.md`, and `output/continuity.md` now contain the Ch13 event and due ripples.
